Okay so it’s my first ever official product review so be kind! Today I’m going to be comparing a high end eye-shadow pallet with a similar budget/ drugstore pallet. I’ve selected Maybelline New York’s ‘The Nudes’ Palette and Urban Decay’s Naked 2 Palette. Nearly every-one I know has one of the coveted Urbay Decay pallets and many people think that while it is a great product, it is waaaaaaaay overpriced. Therefore I thought Id share with you guys what I think is a fairly good dupe for Naked 2 (my personal favourite Urban Decay palette).
High End: Urban Decay Naked 2 Eyeshadow Palette; RRP: $83.00 from Mecca Maxima
Budget: Maybelline New York’s The Nudes Palette; RRP $25.95 from Priceline
Each palette consists of 12 shades and I found that 10 were similar. I unfortunately couldn’t find budget dupes for Pistol and Verve in Naked 2 in The Nudes palette.
The eyeshadows in The Nudes do not have names, and so I’ve numbered each from left to right as 1,2,3,4,5 & 6 and the bottom shades from left to right as 7,8,9,10,11 & 12.
The shades in Naked 2 from left to right are called; Foxy, Half Baked, Booty Call, Chopper, Tease, Snakebite, Suspect, Pistol, Verve, YDK, Busted & Blackout:
The Nudes packaging is very lightweight (would be great for travelling), while Naked 2 is very bulky and heavier. I’ll move straight onto swatches so you can all compare the quality yourselves. Naked 2 shades are on the left and The Nude’s shades are on the right.
- Foxy vs Shade 3: Foxy clearly wins out here- it is far more pigmented. Shade 3 is buildable however it would take a lot more time and effort to replicate the effortlessly pigmented Foxy.
2) Half Baked vs Shade 9: Wow! These shades are so similar! I think this is a near exact dupe in terms of quality and colour.
3) Bootycall vs Shade 1: Neither of these are all that pigmented but it you used these with Mac Fix Plus then you would probably get a better result
4) Chopper vs Shade 4: Shade 4 is darker than chopper but these are both beautiful metallic bronzes with a hint of a shimmer finish.
5) Tease vs Shade 8: These are both really similar in terms of colour and both are true mattes. Shade 8 is slightly less pigmented however.
6) Snakebite vs Shade 10: I love both of these colours so much. Snakebite has a slightly more gold-shimmer finish however both are super pigmented and are great to use with a bronze smokey eye.
7) Suspect vs Shade 2: Again, suspect has more of a gold frost finish but both would be great in a bronze/brown smokey eye.
8) YDK vs Shade 7: The base colour is similar however YDK has a shimmer finish unlike Shade 7. If you really wanted to replicate YDK you could layer any neutral shimmer shade over Shade 7. Here I think YDK is a much nicer and more bold shade.
9) Busted vs Shade 6: Both of these are a-m-a-z-i-n-g browns- the only difference being the Shade 6 is slightly more matte and definitely more pigmented!
10) Blackout vs Shade 12: Yikes, here you clearly see the difference between an $83 product and a $25.95 product. Shade 12 has terrible colour pay-off whereas Blackout is the complete opposite.
So there you have it! Obviously some colours in The Nudes are better than others, e.g. Shade 9, 4 & 8 are amazing whereas Shade 12 and 1 are pretty terrible- you get what you pay for though. I think The Nudes has some really great shades, especially the bronzes, coppers & browns. The less pigmented colours are buildable, and if you wanted to do a brown or black smokey eye using just one pallet then this could easily be achieved with either pallets. Naked 2 is vegan & cruelty free wooohooo! Like most drug-store brands, Maybelline unfortunately does test on animals and is not vegan friendly 😦
All shades (with the exception of Bootycall) in Naked 2 are amazing and I think Maybelline has done a great job (whether intentional or not) in creating an eyeshadow palette which rivals high-end products in terms of quality and colours. At the end of the day, Maybelline ‘The Nudes’ is more than 3 X cheaper than Naked 2 and most of the colours are really similar. I would recommend The Nudes to anyone who is travelling and wants a lightweight and versatile pallet, to anyone who wants a palette to practice eye-looks with and also to anyone who is not willing to pay $83.00 for an eye-shadow palette.
On the other hand, If you a willing to invest $83.00 into a palette that is consistently high-quality, ultra pigmented and features a beautiful mixture of true mattes and shimmer shades, then I can’t recommend naked 2 highly enough. I various shades from mine nearly everyday and has lasted 9+ months plus it comes with the added bonus of being cruelty-free and vegan!
Thanks for reading- TriedAndTestedBeautyProducts x
*All images by TriedAndTestedBeautyProducts